Start networking and exchanging professional insights

Register now or log in to join your professional community.

Follow

What Works: Fresh blood or old hands? Experience or Novicity?

user-image
Question added by Nikita Bhatia , HR Intern - Centre for Legal Training , Al Tamimi & Company
Date Posted: 2017/10/02
Deleted user
by Deleted user

There is no good alternative to experience! Those with years of experience know what works and what does NOT work and probably, most importantly, they know WHY.  Time has thinned the ranks to add value to those with direct experience.  There is only danger and hazard with "fresh blood" willing to try new things before knowing the risks.  Fresh blood willing to listen to experience and knowledge are helpful when greater volume is needed, but those who won't follow the example of old hands with experience will likely get eliminated.

Obaid ur Rehman
by Obaid ur Rehman , HR Executive , Al Bahr Al Arabi Marine Engineering Services

Both. fresg blood having experiences of old hands is worth working. 

Gasser Mohamad Abdul Wahab Ali
by Gasser Mohamad Abdul Wahab Ali , Warehouse And Logistics Manager , Ahleia Electrical Co. W.l.l

Thanks for invite But I think both of them are wanted regarding the position or job title

Omar Saad Ibrahem Alhamadani
by Omar Saad Ibrahem Alhamadani , Snr. HR & Finance Officer , Sarri Zawetta Company

Thanks 

In my opinion, Both 

Old hands with experience for managerial positions, fresh blood for executive position Old hands with experience for managerial positions, fresh blood for executive position 

Nikunj Thaker
by Nikunj Thaker , Assistant Manager , Head of Compliance – International Financial Services (Qatar) LLC

Experience in the relevant/diverse field gives a person broad view of the exact requirements of the function. At the same time it is also paramount importance, in today's IT Era, that one needs to be aware of latest developments (how IT is helpful) in the chosen domain and try to gain exposure on the same to give an edge to the experience gained.

by , Administrative Supervisor , Wadi Jana Company

Some jobs need expertise and Some jobs require new staff This depends on the type of function to be filled For example, the position of financial manager must be a financial manager with experience and knowledge Either the accountant or data entry would prefer to have brushes so that I have an ambitious for learning

boualem larbi
by boualem larbi , مراقب , الديوان الوطني للاحصائيات

Welcome needs and requirements in addition to a comprehensive analysis of the environment of the decision and its various components determine this

Anfal Salim Al Siyabi
by Anfal Salim Al Siyabi , Admin & HR intern , Al Marafiq CompanyAl Qurum

I think Fresh Blood would have got a wider mind that is not restricted to ideas set previously. A fresh blood has more ability to innovate, brainstorm, develop diverse methods, and is more flexible and can adabt with any environment. Whereas old hands are restricted to the given tasks and they tend to stick with what have been learned even with changing environment, simply, they refuse to change.

So in my own thought , if i was to choose between two i would select the fresh blood one. 

More Questions Like This