Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

Do you think that translation jobs are in real danger facing the machine translation services?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Lina Samer , Digital Media Graphic Designer , iDirection
Date de publication: 2018/01/18
Fabio Gagliardi
par Fabio Gagliardi , Language Coach , TurboLangs

It is a very interesting field of research with great advancement. Still, as anything else in the AI environment, it has to go a long way before to become a danger for any human translator.

Anyway, it doesn't harm, for translators and interpreters with a knack for coding and technology, to take a peek at it. Computer programmers still need to know about how languages work, so language experts can participate actively in this revolution, instead of being victims like they are often depicted to be.

I do believe, however, on the contrary of opinions expressed here, that one day Machine Translation will be human-like and beyond. At that point, those who would learn a language out of obligation will be able to stop doing so, whereas those who learn it because they love it, will not be refrained nevertheless.

Fatma El Zahraa Khalil
par Fatma El Zahraa Khalil , Temporary Administrative /Personal Assistant , "EIA" Emirates Investment Authority - Abu Dhabi, UAE

Translation jobs is totally different than the electronic one; it helps but can't be a replacer

Nouf Sh El Sheikh Alhabash
par Nouf Sh El Sheikh Alhabash , News Chief-editor / News Editor / Translator , Ministry of Information

I don't think so .. when we translate we convert the culture of a language .. not only convert the meaning of certain words .. machines cannot do that

sullivan donbesty
par sullivan donbesty , Worker , Admin assistance manager

Yes when it comes to operates

Nourane Farahat
par Nourane Farahat , digital marketing specialist , Anasia Group

no! the machine translation service offers no sense words and experssions, on the other hand human translator give you lively experssions and idioms. 

Muhammed Noaman
par Muhammed Noaman , Senior Executive- Training and Development , Contact Centers Company- STC

No doubt that machine translation services took a place in the translation industry and they are really doing a good job, but it will never replace the human efforts and human brain possibilities.

Mohammad Saleem Akbar
par Mohammad Saleem Akbar , Export SALES AND MARKETING Executive , Deeko Bahrain WLL

No absolutely not. Machine cannot determine correct choice of word for or your target audiance.  We can get help but writing a professions letter or translation for 100% correct meaning we must need a native person of that particular Language.

 

 

Utilisateur supprimé
par Utilisateur supprimé

The current trend of electronic translation apps and devices have improved their capability greatly.  However, for the foreseeable future, I don't see this as a threat to human translation services for a simple reason.  People can interpret the tone and intent of a message, especially idioms and colloquial dialects, that a program may not be able to and make the crossovers in text that a direct literal translation cannot supply.

Interpreting and expressing the goals of a speaker or writer from one language into a second language still requires the human touch...for now.

Homam Ouyon Al Nabelsi
par Homam Ouyon Al Nabelsi , Freelance Translator , Le Reve Translation

I won't deny that the machine development is getting better and better over time...but we asked the same question back when the first machine was invented...and still, it didn't replace humans in other jobs. So, I don't think that will happen.

According to my experience ,the machine and technology may not repace human translators , it may help them work better. The translator needs to feel the meaning of the sentences to be able to translate correctly .

Mohammed Abdel Hammeid
par Mohammed Abdel Hammeid , Import manager , Pyram Engineering and Trading Company

Of course, accuracy of machine translation is increasing by time, if you revise google translator as a sample example from 5 years and compare with accuracy nowadays, you will find great development happened.

More Questions Like This