Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

What is the best way to give negative and posetive feedbacks to the learners?

What is the best way to give negative and posetive feedback to the learners?

user-image
Question ajoutée par Nelson Mabote , General Receptionist/ Administration , Toyo
Date de publication: 2018/04/09
oussama khay
par oussama khay , Technical supervisor , Kaeser

In my experience, the best way is not to denigrate him no matter what he has done and to show him gently and listen to him.

eslam khalil
par eslam khalil , Full Stack Web Developer , عمل حر

Giving feedback to learners in a way that motivates and guides improvement is essential. Here’s an approach that balances both positive and negative feedback effectively:

### 1. **Start with the Positive (The "Sandwich" Method)**
- Begin with specific positive feedback. Highlight what they’re doing well and how it’s contributing to their learning. This builds their confidence and makes them more receptive to constructive feedback.
- Example: “You’ve done a great job organizing your thoughts and presenting your ideas clearly. It really shows your dedication.”

### 2. **Be Specific and Objective with Negative Feedback**
- Address specific behaviors or aspects that need improvement rather than making general statements. Focus on actions, not personality, so the learner understands what to improve without feeling criticized.
- Example: “One area to work on is expanding on your ideas with examples. This can help make your explanations even clearer.”

### 3. **Use a Growth-Oriented Tone**
- Frame negative feedback as an opportunity for growth rather than as a failure. This can motivate learners to see the feedback as part of their improvement journey.
- Example: “By adding more examples, you’ll strengthen your communication skills and make a bigger impact on your audience.”

### 4. **Provide Actionable Suggestions**
- Give specific advice on how they can improve. Concrete steps make feedback more practical and less overwhelming.
- Example: “For your next presentation, try to include one or two examples for each main point. This will make your points more relatable and memorable.”

### 5. **Encourage Self-Reflection**
- Ask the learner to reflect on what they think went well and what could be improved. This builds critical thinking and gives them ownership of their progress.
- Example: “What part of your work do you feel the most confident about? Is there anything you’d like to do differently next time?”

### 6. **End with Encouragement**
- Conclude with positive reinforcement. Remind them of their strengths and progress, which keeps them motivated to tackle any areas for improvement.
- Example: “You’ve already made a lot of progress, and with a few adjustments, you’ll see even more improvement. Keep up the great work!”

This approach not only helps learners accept and act on feedback but also builds their confidence and encourages a growth mindset. It maintains a supportive environment where they feel empowered to improve.

Maria Christopher
par Maria Christopher , IMS - Internal MR & Document controller , M A H Y Khoory

Positive Feedback Be Specific: Highlight exact strengths (e.g., "Your project analysis was well-structured"). Encourage Growth: Suggest ways to build on their strengths. Timeliness: Provide feedback soon after the task. Foster a Positive Environment: Create a supportive atmosphere. Negative Feedback Use the “Sandwich” Approach: Start with positives, address areas for improvement, then end on a positive note. Focus on Behavior: Critique actions, not the individual (e.g., "There are errors in your report" instead of "You're careless"). Be Constructive: Offer solutions for improvement. Encourage Dialogue: Invite their input and reflection. Follow Up: Check in on their progress later.

Nasir Husain
par Nasir Husain , Director Planning Construction and Maintenance , IIMS&R Medical College and Hospital

first meeting with the guy and understnd his problem than give him solution in a technical and moral support if needed as well

babar bashir
par babar bashir , Compensation and benifits manager , Bata Shoe Company

Assess the Situation: Gather information about the employee’s behavior and its impact on the team. Speak with other team members to understand the extent of the issue.

Alaa Saraya
par Alaa Saraya , Architectural Interior Designer , Layers showroom

Present a balanced perspective that encourages positive behaviors while recognizing the negative ones they need to work through. It is important not to mislead and yet offer some positive points to remain motivated.

Sravani Jonnalagadda
par Sravani Jonnalagadda

Be honest and sincere. we are ofter aware of our underperformance,so the feedback should not be a surprise

Ahishakiye dodos Patrick
par Ahishakiye dodos Patrick , Social Media Sales Professional , RADIO TV10

Giving feedback to learners, whether positive or negative, is crucial for their growth and development. Here are some effective strategies for delivering both types of feedback:

  Positive Feedback
  1. Be Specific: Instead of saying "Good job," specify what the learner did well. For example, "You did an excellent job explaining the concept of photosynthesis; your examples were clear and relevant."

     
  2. Encourage Reflection: Ask learners how they felt about their performance. This encourages self-assessment and reinforces their understanding of what they did well.

     
  3. Use the "Sandwich" Method: Start with positive feedback, then provide constructive criticism (if necessary), and finish with more positive remarks. This helps maintain motivation.

     
  4. Acknowledge Effort: Recognize the effort put into the work, not just the outcome. For instance, "I appreciate the hard work you put into your project; it really shows in the final product."

     
  5. Celebrate Achievements: Celebrate milestones and achievements, no matter how small. This boosts confidence and encourages continued effort.

     
Negative Feedback
  1. Be Constructive: Focus on the behavior or work, not the individual. Use phrases like "This part of your essay needs more evidence" instead of "You are not a good writer."

     
  2. Be Specific and Actionable: Provide clear examples of what needs improvement and suggest specific actions the learner can take to improve. For example, "Try to provide more examples to support your arguments in future essays."

     
  3. Use a Supportive Tone: Approach the conversation with empathy and a desire to help. Make it clear that your goal is to support their growth.

     
  4. Encourage Dialogue: Allow learners to ask questions or express their thoughts about the feedback. This can lead to a better understanding and a collaborative approach to improvement.

     
  5. Follow Up: After giving negative feedback, check in with the learner to see how they are progressing. This shows that you care about their development and are there to support them.

     
  6. Balance with Positivity: Even when giving negative feedback, try to balance it with positive comments about their strengths or potential. This helps maintain motivation and a positive mindset.

     

By using these strategies, you can create a supportive learning environment that encourages growth and development through both positive and negative feedback.

Jabu Mqwati
par Jabu Mqwati , Safety Officer , Pulsar Africa Systems (PTY) LTD

Is to be frank in whatever feedback you giving whether bad or good but be honest

Wael Ali
par Wael Ali , مدير اغذية ومشروبات او مساعد مدير اغذية ومشروبات , رمادا

First, I apologize to the customer with my sincerest thoughts

Start by providing feedback on specific strengths or positive aspects of the person to whom you will be providing feedback. ...Then clarify the specific areas that need improvement or those in which some changes need to be made.End your feedback with a positive comment, such as encouragement or praise.

After that, I will take the necessary action with the chef who prepared the food

MOHAMMAD SIDDIQUI
par MOHAMMAD SIDDIQUI , CLINICAL STAFF PHARMACIST , HCA HEALTHCARE CORPORATION

MAKE THEM COMFORTABLE AND ENCOURAGE THEM TO ASK QUESTIONS , NO QUESTION IS A STUPID QUESTION

More Questions Like This