Communiquez avec les autres et partagez vos connaissances professionnelles

Inscrivez-vous ou connectez-vous pour rejoindre votre communauté professionnelle.

Suivre

In architectural designing, Can revit replace 3ds max at the initial stage of a project ??

user-image
Question ajoutée par RAMACHANDRAN KOZHIKOTTU PARAMBIL , Sr. ARCHITECTURAL DRAUGHTSMAN , SHAPOORJI PALLONJI
Date de publication: 2013/06/05
Mohamed Ibraheem Noordeen
par Mohamed Ibraheem Noordeen , Project Engineer , Stree Group of Companies

First of all3Ds max is not a BIM (Building Information Modelling) software.
It's just a3D graphics tools.
People use3Ds Max just for producing the high quality rendered image of the architectural design and walk through movies of the design.
Make a model in Revit Arch and export it to3Ds max for rendering and for dynamic walk through is the best practice done.

Sagi Darali
par Sagi Darali , BIM Discipline Head , CCC

Three reasons why Revit rendering is better at "INITIAL PHASE" or "DESIGN PHASE":

1. You will save alot of time by Rendering directly in Revit, rather than exporting and importing and setting up another lighting system, fixing modeling issues etc...

2. You will do yourself and the project a big favour by assigning correct material in Revit, because Revit material can be part of the delivarable information, and can be scheduled and quantified.

3. Revit rendering capabilities has been improved drastically in the past few years almost to the level of professional renderers. It has built in Mental Ray engine, with simpler interface than3DS Max.

 

On the other hand, if you need high-end renderings with professional-grade effects and more importantly animated environments and people, then you have to use3D Studio Max. This can be at the final stage of a design proposal for use in selling or marketing your design, if the project size justifies the production cost and time.

Omare Muhammad Azam Khan
par Omare Muhammad Azam Khan , Incharge n Technical Training Instructor , Autodesk College - AC


1- Because the philosophy of Revit & Max is entirely different.
2- So in some stages it may be the replacement but not all.
3- But out there what you mean by in initial stage, its unclear ?
4- So it will not be possible to answer the question perfectly.

Benj Salisipan
par Benj Salisipan , Architect , MMC

3DMax is a presentation Tool and is not accurate. The visulaizer with design intent enhances some areas it want to emphasize to the client, sometimes distorting the image to achieve a result. Whilst Revit, from preparing onto2d layout, encoding the finishes, materials is as accurate as we could get when presenting onto perspective.

So, can we replace the3dmax with Revit. With the above statements which do you prefer, accuracy or presentation.

For me, with more than20 years of professional experience in General construction, Civil work, Interior Fit out, I vote for Revit.  

Lavina Daryani
par Lavina Daryani , Senior Interior Designer , a&o Hostels GmbH & Co. KG

Yes it is a better idea to use Revit initially because it gives you accurate measurements and makes it very easy to create sections of the outer building or floor. The only reason why 3ds Max is preferred over Revit in the later stages is that Revit limits the modification of furniture and rendering quality while 3ds max is one of the worlds leading software to create realistic views and representations.

Utilisateur supprimé
par Utilisateur supprimé

Absolutely yes!

Mohammed Abduljabbar Mohammed Fateh
par Mohammed Abduljabbar Mohammed Fateh , Engineering , Vision Engineering

- First of all3Ds max is not a BIM (Building Information Modelling) software. It's just a3D graphics tools.

- but there is onther way take the measurnment and area in autocad program then you can transfer your drawing into3d max

Imaan Ali
par Imaan Ali , Project and Export Engineer , Jawdah Industrial Co. Ltd.

Any software is repraceable at any stage as far as the person operating knows how to work the program

aida gomaa
par aida gomaa , instructar , privet university

first thing you can draw the accualy measurnment and area onto autocad program then you can transfer your drawing into3d max

More Questions Like This